Posts

Showing posts with the label Jersey Justice System

One Good Man — Part Five: Leave the Lawyers to Sort It Out

Image
 There is a phrase which seems to sit somewhere in the background of almost every bureaucracy: "Leave the lawyers to sort it out." It is a remarkably convenient phrase. The civil servant can make the decision. The administrator can impose the condition. The prison officer can take the action. The politician can announce the policy. And if somebody complains that what has been done is unlawful, unfair or unjust, there is always another department waiting somewhere in the background. The lawyers will sort it out. Except that lawyers are not some magical mechanism for turning injustice into justice. They are human beings too. And they operate within an economic system. The Price of Justice One of the most uncomfortable things I have learned from my experiences with the Jersey legal system is how quickly the question of justice can become a question of economics. How much is the case worth? How much can the client afford? How much time can be justi...

One Good Man — Part Four: The Evil of Doing

Image
There is something else I have learned from watching institutions operate. We have been taught that doing something is better than doing nothing. Action is regarded as virtuous. Initiative is praised. Activity is treated as evidence of competence. We admire the person who takes charge, solves the problem and gets things moving. But what if that assumption is wrong? What if sometimes the most moral thing a person can do is nothing? The Virtue of Restraint There are circumstances in which action is obviously necessary. If somebody is in immediate danger, doing nothing may be unconscionable. If something is broken and needs repairing, somebody has to repair it. If an injustice is taking place in front of you, there may be a moral obligation to intervene. But there are other circumstances where the consequences of acting are uncertain. You do not have all the information. You do not understand the situation. You do not know what will happen if you interfere....

One Good Man — Part Three: How Evil Works

Image
Perhaps one of the most important things I have learned from my experiences with the Jersey justice system is that evil does not necessarily look like evil. That may sound like an obvious statement. But it is not. We tend to imagine evil as something obvious. We imagine somebody who knows that what they are doing is wrong and does it anyway. We imagine cruelty. We imagine hatred. We imagine somebody deliberately setting out to cause harm. But I have come to believe that some of the most dangerous forms of evil arise when people genuinely believe that what they are doing is good. The Good Person Most people do not wake up in the morning and decide that they are going to do something evil. They wake up believing that they are good people. They go to work. They do their jobs. They follow the procedures. They answer their emails. They attend their meetings. They make decisions. And they go home believing that they have done what was expected of them. They ...

One Good Man — Part Two: The Warning Before Destruction

Image
There is another biblical story which has been occupying my thoughts. It is the story of Jonah and Nineveh. Unlike Abraham, Jonah is not negotiating with God over how many righteous people might be found within a wicked society. Jonah is given a much simpler task. He is told to go to Nineveh and warn its people that destruction is coming. Jonah does not want to do it. He runs away. But eventually Jonah finds himself back on the path that God has chosen for him, and he goes to Nineveh. He delivers the message. The city is going to be destroyed. And then something remarkable happens. The people listen. They recognise what they have been doing. They repent. And God does not destroy them. The Purpose of a Warning There is something important about this story which is very easily overlooked. If destruction had been the only objective, there would have been no need for Jonah. There would have been no need for a warning. There would have been no need for ...

One Good Man — Part One: The One Good Man

Image
There is an old biblical question which has occupied my thoughts for some time. How many good people does it take to save a society? The question appears most famously in the story of Abraham and Sodom. Abraham stands before God and questions the justice of destroying an entire city. What if there are fifty righteous people within it? Would it really be right to destroy the righteous along with the wicked? God agrees that He would spare the city for the sake of the fifty. But Abraham continues. What about forty-five? Forty? Thirty? Twenty? Ten? And so Abraham gradually negotiates the number down, each time asking whether the existence of a smaller number of righteous people would be sufficient reason for the city to be spared. It is a remarkable conversation. It suggests that the moral character of a society cannot simply be separated from the actions of the individuals within it. The existence of goodness matters. The existence of people who are prepared to s...